Legal Studies students Libby Austin and Charlee Rose Murtough-Coombes found the 2023 HSC exam reasonable, but like many of their peers found Question 25 ‘a little confusing’. Picture: Max Mason-Hubers
A fifteen-mark question on crime and courts threw some HSC students through a loop as they sat down for their three-hour Legal Studies exam.
Legal Studies teacher at Emmaus Catholic College in western Sydney Carmen Rojo said the exam overall was a fair one, and that scoring highly in the fifteen-marker would come down to how well students understand the legislation, such as police powers.
“When it comes to compliance with the courts, (courts) need to make sure that those people in power are following things like the Evidence Act,” Ms Rojo added.
“(Students) need their LCIDs – legislation, case, international documents and media articles … to link to the answer.”
The question in question: Number 25 in the 2023 Legal Studies HSC Exam, the most controversial question in the test. Picture: NSW Education Standards Authority
Her students, Year 12 graduates and keen debaters Charlee Rose Murtough-Coombes and Libby Austin, both found Question 25 “a little confusing”, at least at first glance.
“It stumped me a little bit because I didn’t understand what they meant by courts advocating for compliance,” Charlee Rose said.
Libby Austin and Charlee Rose Murtough-Coombes, Year 12 students at Emmaus Catholic College in Kemps Creek, had their HSC Legal Studies exam on Wednesday morning. Picture: Max Mason-Hubers
“But then I took it (meaning) what happens in the courtroom … and then outside local courts, they do AA meetings and … domestic violence meetings. They do the educational stuff as well, so I just took that and ran with it.”
“Once I broke it down … I think I was pretty well-prepared by talking about punishment and awareness kind of forcing society’s hand,” Libby said.
“I answered that question to the best of my capabilities, so I’m pretty confident going out of the exam that we both did well.”
Both 18-year-olds will continue to take exams for other subjects over the coming weeks. HSC exams conclude on November 3 with the Food Technology paper.
Catholic Schools Parramatta Diocese
www.parra.catholic.edu.au
-
![Catholic School Open Days - Catholic Education Diocese of Parramatta]()
01 Feb 2025
Catholic School Open Days
We are enrolling now! Attend your local Catholic school's Open Day to find out more.![ARTiculate HSC Visual Arts Showcase Catholic Schools Parramatta Diocese]()
Instagram | CSPD
More News
22 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
Such an amazing morning and we're so proud of our STARS from Holy Family Primary School, East Granville🤩⚡️💖 who got to showcase their amazing school to all of Australia on the Today show on Channel 9.📺🌦☀️ 👀👀😄Check out the highlights in this video or you can watch the full segments via the link in our bio. The show touched on the school's upcoming Vinnies NSW Winter Sleepout😴🥱, Garden Club🥕🍓☘️, their beautiful Indigenous mural and mascot Buk Buk🦉, their school expectations and they even got to declare their allegiances to their favourite NRL clubs and unanimous support for the NSW Blues.🏉💙💙 @holyfamilyprimarygranville #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney #bluemountainsnsw #parramatta #hawkesbury #eastgranville #granville @vinniesnsw @nrl @nswblues
21 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
🎶🎤🎸Music, dance, prayer and discussion 🙏👏😄 - must be a LIFTED event! Presented by CSPD's Mission team and Catholic Youth Parramatta, these inspirational formation events have been attended by students across the diocese. The high-energy sessions have left the students feeling full of hope for the future and filled with a deep appreciation of their faith. 🥰✝ 👉 Religious education takes many forms in our schools, to learn more visit our website - link in our bio above! @catholicyouthparra @catherinemcauleywestmead @stjohnxxiiicatholiccollege @xavierllandilo @stjosephsprimarykingswoodnsw @staidansprimaryrootyhill #stjohnvianneysprimaryschool #goodshepherdprimaryplumpton #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney
20 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
🌟 TV STAR IN THE MAKING!🌟 Ryan from St Anthony's Primary Girraween took the spotlight on the TODAY show's 'Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?' – and absolutely nailed it! 🧠🎉 From tackling tricky science questions on photosynthesis to naming Australia’s first Prime Minister, Ryan wowed the nation with his smarts, confidence, and cool under pressure. We couldn’t be prouder – way to represent, Ryan! 🙌📺👏 #stanthonysprimarygirraween #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney #todayshow #areyousmarterthana5thgrader Be sure to check out Ryan's school, St Anthony's, on their website to find out about the excellent education on offer.
19 May 2025
From CSPD YouTube
19 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
❤️💛🖤Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Senior Students Forum 2025❤️💛🖤 Hosted by CSPD's Jarara Cultural Centre and St Columba's College Springwood this special event was a day of culture, connection and possibility for students from around the diocese. Highlights included a keynote address 🗣️ from renowned Aboriginal author and justice advocate, Thomas Mayo; a student panel; cultural workshops and dances🪃🦘🔥; and a pathways expo. 🥰CSPD is committed to supporting all students to succeed. To learn more about the work of our Jarara Cultural Centre in walking with our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students visit out website: ==>parra.catholic.edu.au/learning/specialised- learning/jarara @columbasdoves @thomasamayo #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney #jararaculturalcentre #aboriginalandtorresstraitislander #seniorstudents #pathwaystosuccess #careersexpo #culture
18 May 2025
From CSPD Facebook
🎒Still in high school and already uni grads!🎓 St Luke's Catholic College is very proud of this group of senior students who recently completed Academy U - a first year university subject on Leadership in Complexity. 🎉 🏫 The program not only gave the students a taste of what uni is like, but they’re also eligible to receive a conditional offer to study at Western Sydney University and are invited to apply for a scholarship. Even better, the subject they’ve completed can count as credit towards their future degree! 🥰 👏 A special congratulations to Mishwa and Anika, who graduated with distinction - what an achievement! 🤯 The future certainly looks bright for these students and we can't wait to see what they do next. 👀 To learn more about the incredible learning opportunities at St Luke's visit their website: ==> stlukesmarsdenpark.catholic.edu.au/why-us
18 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
We're so incredibly proud of the efforts of all our schools who were involved in the Caritas Australia Big Water Walk fundraiser. Over $100,000 raised to help provide clean water for those less fortunate than us here in Australia. #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #westernsydney #parracatholic #caritasaustralia #bigwaterwalk #fundraiser Caritas Australia Diocese of Parramatta
17 May 2025
From CSPD Facebook
❤️💛🖤A day of CULTURE, CONNECTION & POSSIBILITY❤️💛🖤 - Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Senior Students Forum 2025. Hosted by CSPD's Jarara Cultural Centre and St Columba's Catholic College, Springwood this special event was an inspiring experience for students from around the diocese. Highlights included a keynote address 🗣️ from renowned Aboriginal author and justice advocate, Thomas Mayo; a student panel; cultural workshops and dances🪃🦘🔥; and a pathways expo. 🥰CSPD is committed to supporting all students to succeed. To learn more about the work of our Jarara Cultural Centre in walking with our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students visit out website: ==> parra.catholic.edu.au/learning/specialised-learning/jarara
17 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
A bit of rain💦 didn’t dampen spirits or the healthy attitude of parents, staff and especially so many students (and even local police👮🚓) for National Walk Safely to School Day🚶♀️🚶♂️💛, showing just how important it is to stay active and safe on our roads. 👟🚦🛣 From holding hands on footpaths to stopping, looking, listening and thinking before crossing 🚦, today was all about building healthy habits and smart road safety skills. 👏 Remeber to always Stop, Look, Listen, Think, everytime you cross the road. Walking is fun. It's a great way to stay healthy, engage with children and our local community.💗💞 #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney #hawkesbury #walksafelytoschool #police #hakwesbury #richmond #glenmoreparkmums @stmonicasrichmond @natwalktoschool
16 May 2025
From CSPD Facebook
Being active🚶♀️🚶♂️👟🥾 and healthy and especially learning about and practicing road safety are such important things for students and parents... which is what makes National Walk Safely to School Day so great!😁🥰 Despite a bit of rain this morning💦🌧, it was wonderful to see so many parents, students, staff and even local police🚓👮 walking safely to school or having conversations about being a safe road user.🛴🚗🚌 Bethany Catholic Primary School, Glenmore Park and St Thomas Aquinas Primary School Springwood were the focus of special stories about the day in their local newspapers.📰🗞🤩 Did you know, you should ALWAYS hold your child's hand when on the footpath, when crossing the road or when in a car park. Teach your child about watching out for driveways, walking facing traffic when there are no footpaths and always Stop, Look, Listen, Think, everytime you cross the road.🚦🛣 Another increasingly important lesson is to remind young people to avoid distractions like mobile phones, devices or toys. And remember, walking is fun. It's a great way to stay healthy, engage with children and our local community.💗💞 St Monica's Primary School Richmond
16 May 2025
From CSPD YouTube
16 May 2025
From CSPD Instagram
All our school communites, especially Emmaus Catholic College couldn't be more proud 🤩🥳or excited for Yer 12 student Layla Sharp who is one of seven Para athletes to receive the Kurt Fearnley Scholarship, recognising her potential for the Glasgow 2026 Commonwealth Games.🏃♀️🥇🎖 What an incredible achievement! 😇🥰👏 Layla, a regular State and National champion, is the World Number 1-ranked female athlete in the T38 800m but has recently shifted her focus to qualifying for the 200m or 400m events at Glasgow.#️⃣1️⃣ The scholarship is named after Kurt Fearnley, one of Australia's most successful Para athletes, winning numerous medals across three Commonwealth Games and five Paralympic Games.🌏🌟✨ Layla was formally recognised at the Carbine Club of NSW Champion’s Lunch and inducted into the program at a session facilitated by Commonwealth Games Australia. #paraathletics #cspd2025 #catholicschoolsparramattadiocese #parracatholic #westernsydney #bluemountainsnsw #parramatta #kempscreek @emmauscspd @laylasharprunning_ @kurtfearnleyinsta @commgamesaus @commonwealthgames2026 @carbinensw
15 May 2025
From CSPD Facebook
From classroom🏫 to clinic🏥: St John XXIII Catholic College alumna inspires the next generation 🩺🧸 We are so proud to see former student, Eilish A’Court (Class of 2019), who is currently studying medicine at The University of Notre Dame Australia and serves as Co-Chair of PANDA (Paediatric Association of Notre Dame Australia) return to her school to lead the Teddy Bear Hospital program! 💛 👩⚕️🩹Alongside fellow med students, she helped Kindergarten students learn about health, nutrition, and doctor visits — all while caring for a few cuddly (and slightly unwell!) teddy bears. 🧸 Inspiring work from a future doctor and incredible role model! 🥰 🙏 St JXXIII students learn the importance of giving back to the community. Learn more about the College at their website: ==> stjohn23stanhope.catholic.edu.au/About-Us/What-We-Offer
15 May 2025
From CSPD YouTube
15 May 2025